Koran 17:59

And nothing has prevented Us from sending signs except that the former peoples denied them.

And We gave Thamud the she-camel as a visible sign, but they wronged her.

And We send not the signs except as a warning.

Koran 17:59

This is Muhammad (“Us”), excusing himself from “sending signs”. Earlier, Muhammad claimed that his verses were “signs” from Allah. So obviously the verse here is no longer a sign. The “she-camel” like every other she-camel was only a sign, at best, for Thamud, not the Quraysh. So, the people of Mecca have not received a sign, except for Muhammad publicly ranting and raving, while pretending to be Allah with “Us”. Also note that the “We” is back, that’s the demon:

The thunder is the words, the thoughts are the lightning.

In this verse, Muhammad’s demon clearly acts as the bad guy, while “Us” is Allah the “good” guy.

For more about the story of Saleh, Thamud and the she-camel, see Story of Saleh.

Note that I had to find out about Saleh, Thamud and the she-camel from collecting the various stories in the Koran, working out that they’re play-acting by Muhammad, and NOT retelling the stories of Thamud, which shows that the Koran is not clear and so not from Allah. The intense narrow focus of the Koran upon the inhabitants of Mecca, and Muhammad’s Muslim bandits, shows that Allah, Islam and Koran are local to Muhammad’s time and place, his context, so showing Muhammad, Allah, Islam and Koran are all false.

The best replacement for this passage is: “”, the empty sentence.

1 thought on “Koran 17:59”

Leave a reply to Qur’an 17:59 – Koran Contradiction Cancel reply