Koran 15:45-50

15:45 Indeed, the righteous will be within gardens and springs. 46 [Having been told], “Enter it in peace, safe [and secure].”

47 And We will remove whatever is in their breasts of resentment, [so they will be] brothers, on thrones facing each other.

48 No fatigue will touch them therein, nor from it will they [ever] be removed.

49 [O Muhammad], inform My servants that it is I who am the Forgiving, the Merciful. 50 And that it is My punishment which is the painful punishment.

Koran 15:45-50

This is one of the stories of Islamic Paradise and it’s one of the few places that Allah speaks as one being in the first person with “I” and “My”. Note the earlier verse which has “We” – that’s Jibril speaking.

Muhammad commits shirk with: “We”, “Us” or “Our”, placing Allah as a companion to himself, showing that Allah is incoherent, imaginary, and fictional, and so Islam is incoherent with monotheism, thus Islam is contradictory and false.

Note how “Allah” “will” speak to Muslims “the righteous” with “Enter it in peace, safe [and secure].” Yet, Allah doesn’t speak to Muslims directly while they’re alive. This shows that this verse is a lie by Muhammad. Muhammad is the only one that “Allah” speaks to, despite Muhammad here lying and saying that Allah will speak to Muslims “the righteous” directly. Thus, this shows that Muhammad is “needed” to speak the words of “Allah”. Yet, Muhammad is dead, and his words were assembled in the wrong order by Muslims. And still, “Allah” doesn’t speak to Muslims and doesn’t get Muhammad’s Allah’s words correctly ordered in Muhammad’s Koran, for over 1400 years. This shows that Allah is dead, a broken, stone idol, incapable of communicating with all Muslims, let alone all humans.

Note the big changes in Islamic Paradise with: “brothers, on thrones facing each other.” This is Muhammad trying to get his Muslim companions to get along with each other: “remove whatever is in their breasts of resentment”. Or it’s simply mind control by imaginary Allah. And of course, “brothers” shows Muhammad’s misogyny, ignoring Muslim women and children. Either way, it’s another reason to reject Islam as Muhammad showed Islamic Paradise is incoherent and nonsensical and only for the Muslim companions of his time: “on thrones facing each other.”

Let’s assume that Muhammad is correct, and all Muslims will become male, instead of being men, women and children as they are now. Let’s assume each throne is a modest 1 meter wide. How do 1.5 billion Muslims fit on these thrones facing each other? A circle with a circumference of 1.5 billion meters, or 1.5 thousand kilometres. Divide by Pi, which means that the circle of thrones is over 475 KM in diameter. How do you see your brother Muslim 2 or more seats across from you, left and right? They’re blocked from your view by the Muslims on your left and right. Now assume that this is all in one room, 500 KM across. How long does it take for all 1.5 billion Muslims to file in, sit down and watch each other? Well, I guess it’s how long it would take you to walk around 250 KM to get to your seat, around 83 hours of continuous walking, or over 3 days of continuous walking, with no stops for meals, sleeping or sex with the virgins of Paradise. As you can see, Muhammad’s circle of thrones is impractical for the current number of believers, thus Islam is false.

Now let’s compare this with Muhammad’s probable number of companions. I’ll assume 12, like the hours on a clock face. The circle of thrones is 12 metres around in circumference and the diameter would be about 4 metres. A three-metre-wide table would be impressive inside the circle. Every Muslim of the 12 can see each other and be seen. This simple visualisation shows that Muhammad thought Islam would remain small and not have 1.5 billion believers in it. Thus, you know Muhammad was talking about his own context, his own Muslims. And you? You, the Muslim reading this, will never be in this circle of deceived believers of Muhammad.

Muhammad changing Islamic Paradise for his companions shows that for Muhammad, peace between his Muslim companions was more important to him, than literally Islamic Paradise, Islam and Allah. The incoherence here shows that Muhammad was a liar, more interested in a forced peace rather than resolving disputes amicably and justly: “remove whatever is in their breasts of resentment”.

Interestingly, the Tafsir Ibn Kathir,15:45, has a story on Muhammad deceiving his first wife, Khadijah, about Islamic Paradise:

Allah commanded me to tell Khadijah the good news of a jeweled palace in Paradise in which there will be no toil and no fatigue.

Tafsir Ibn Kathir,15:45

Obviously to an old woman, a merchant like Khadijah, a “jeweled palace” with “no toil and no fatigue” would tempt her to support Muhammad. Also note the difference between what Khadijah supposedly gets, a “jeweled palace”, and what Muhammad’s Muslim companions get: “thrones facing each other”. Obviously, this is yet another point of incoherence for Islamic Paradise, showing that Muhammad changes his lies about Islamic Paradise to suit the person or people he’s deceiving.

Also note the threat from “Allah” promising painful punishment, an Appeal to Force fallacy, “And that it is My punishment which is the painful punishment.” You can tell it’s Muhammad speaking here.

Muhammad’s Islamic Paradise bends to Muhammad’s will, but is a mirage in the desert, of no substance, leading everyone astray and in circles. As such, the best replacement for this passage is: “”, the empty sentence.