Koran 15:14-15

15:14 And [even] if We opened to them a gate from the heaven and they continued therein to ascend, 15 They would say, “Our eyes have only been dazzled. Rather, we are a people affected by magic.”

Koran 15:14-15

Muhammad commits shirk with: “We”, “Us” or “Our”, placing Allah as a companion to himself, showing that Allah is incoherent, imaginary, and fictional, and so Islam is incoherent with monotheism, thus Islam is contradictory and false.

Look at how Muhammad, or the Demon (“We”), gets the gate direction wrong: “a gate from the heaven”. Surely, this should be “a gate TO Heaven”? Let’s check out Tafsir Ibn Kathir, 15:14-15:

a gate to the heavens

Tafsir Ibn Kathir, 15:14-15

So, perhaps this is a translation issue? But note that the translation has “the heaven” and the tafsir has “the heavens”. I wonder which is right? Is it the heavens above?

Or is it “the Heaven”?

I’m a disbeliever, an agnostic atheist, and a stairway to the Heavens or Heaven would be very convincing to me. For example, this is a NASA concept of a gate to the heavens above, a space elevator or “beanstalk”.

A space elevator would be tremendously useful to all on Earth allowing far cheaper access to zero-G, orbit and space minerals, to avoid pollution on Earth. Muhammad and Allah creating one, say in Saudi Arabia, would enable Saudi Arabia to be beyond a modern-day super-power, and would let Muslims literally rule all of Earth economically let alone militarily and thus make Islam a global religion, ensuring the triumph of Islam over all. Surely, Allah would be pleased by this outcome?

But, as you can see, Muhammad is NOT guided by a real god and doesn’t know the advantages of a space elevator, a gateway to the heavens above. Thus Allah is a false god, Muhammad a false prophet, Islam is a false religion and the Koran is a book of nonsense and lies.

So let’s assume that it was supposed to be a gateway to Heaven instead.

Let’s note that it’s to “Heaven” not to Islamic Paradise, which seems really strange to me. Let’s look at that sentence again: “if We opened to them a gate from the heaven”. Why doesn’t Muhammad have “Paradise” there instead of “heaven”? Or is it the demon (“We”) speaking instead? The demon would know that Muhammad’s Paradise is literally incoherent, false and nonsensical, as I show in Islamic Paradise, and thus lies: “a gate from the heaven” or deludes: “a gate to the heavens” in Tafsir. As the demon has no power to do either (being forbidden from Heaven), the demon then lies about the Quraysh to Muhammad:

They would say, “Our eyes have only been dazzled. Rather, we are a people affected by magic.”

Koran 15:15

Note how the Demon speaks in plural with “They”, “Our” and “we”. Remember, this can’t be quoting the real leader of Muhammad’s tribe, as this is supposedly a theoretical future with “would”, thus contradicting Muhammad’s concept of Islamic Fate.

Now let’s assume that Muhammad is actually a prophet for a REAL god, who DOES have a “Heaven” and NOT an imaginary Islamic Paradise. Then obviously a REAL gate and REAL stairway to Heaven would be a tremendous benefit for all Muslims and all unbelievers too! A stairway that anyone, even unbelievers and polytheists, could ascend and be transitioned to the gates of Heaven itself, where people could SEE and TALK through the gates to their dead relatives and ancestors who happened to go to Heaven, would be a HUGE boost to Islam or the real religion that has a gate and stairs to Heaven.

And naturally, a stairway to Heaven would also have,… a stairway to Hell. There everyone who cares could descend down to Hell and confirm the horrible stories of the poor people condemned there! Wow! What a sign!

But as Muhammad or the Demon, can’t open these gates to either or both, they both show their lack of power or lack of permission. Muhammad has no power for a real god and the demon enjoys life inside Muhammad better than the dreariness of Hell.

Thus we know that Muhammad was a false prophet for a false god, Allah, for a false religion, Islam, with a false recitation. As such, the best replacement for this passage is: “”, the empty sentence.