Koran 9:79

Those who criticize the contributors among the believers concerning [their] charities and [criticize] the ones who find nothing [to spend] except their effort, so they ridicule them – Allah will ridicule them, and they will have a painful punishment.

Koran 9:79

Muhammad spoke about Allah in the third person. This means this passage is not the perfect words of the perfect Qur’an from perfect Allah. Thus, Allah is false, imaginary, and fictional, which means Islamic doctrine and Islam are nonsensical and false.

Note that this verse was revealed AFTER the fact, as shown by Tafsir Ibn Kathir, 9:79:

When the verses of charity were revealed, we used to work as porters. A man came and distributed objects of charity in abundance and they (hypocrites) said, “He is showing off.” Another man came and gave a Sa` (a small measure of food grains); they said, “Allah is not in need of this small amount of charity.” Then the Ayah was revealed;

Tafsir Ibn Kathir, 9:79

Note that this verse, revealed after the fact, shows that Muhammad can’t prophesy and can’t think ahead. This means Allah is impotent and incoherent, thus imaginary, fictional and false. This means Islamic doctrine and Islam are incoherent, nonsensical and false.

Worse, this problem can trivially be fixed by making charity PRIVATE instead of public as Muhammad let it. Public charity, as Muhammad had it, is open to abuse, ridicule and boasting as the example in Tafsir shows.

Muhammad was unable to think ahead and implement private charity. Instead, he let charity be public and then had to forbid boasting and ridicule instead. Muhammad also couldn’t work out what was suitable for all for charity ahead of time and had to go with his men’s best efforts, instead of to a standard, imposed by Allah. This shows that Allah is not consulted by Muhammad, that Allah is simply an aspect of Muhammad, impotent, incoherent, imaginary, fictional and false. This means that Islamic doctrine and Islam are incoherent, nonsensical and false. This means that the best replacement for this verse is: “”, the empty sentence.