Koran 50:12-15

50:12 The people of Noah denied before them, and the companions of the well and Thamūd 13 And Aad and Pharaoh and the brothers [i.e., people] of Lot 14 And the companions of the thicket and the people of Tubba.

All denied the messengers, so My threat was justly fulfilled.

15 Did We fail in the first creation?

But they are in confusion over a new creation.

Koran 50:12-15

Muhammad name drops, trying to threaten, when obviously these are not messengers for Allah at all. Noah was ordered to save his family and the animals, by YHWH, not to be a messenger. Muhammad’s failure to know this from the stories in Torah and Bible, condemns him as a false prophet. For more, see: Story of Noah.

Muhammad’s continued failure in not naming the other supposed messengers of Allah, like “the companions of the well”, and “the companions of the thicket”, shows his failures in remembering their names. This is incompetence, incoherent with the supposed perfect nature of Allah.

• The “companions of the well” could refer to: Koran 36:13-32, no one knows for sure.
• The people called “Thamūd” refers to the Story of Saleh.
• The LAND of “ʿAad”, not people, refers to the Story of Hud.
• The ruler, not people, Pharaoh, refers to the Story of Moses and the Israelites.
• The “brothers [i.e., people] of Lot” refers to the cities of Sodom and Gomorrah in Story of Lot, who were NOT brothers or people of Lot.
• The “companions of the thicket” refers to the Story of Shuaib.
• The “people of Tubbaʿ” refers to a story in Koran 44:34-37.

As you can see, I explain to the best of my ability, but Muhammad and Allah can’t explain at all, and get things wrong. This is obvious incompetence on the part of Muhammad and Allah, showing Allah is Muhammad, Muhammad is Allah, both are dust and so Islam and Koran are false.

So Muhammad’s rhetorical question: “Did We fail in the first creation?” has the unexpected answer of: “Yes, you did fail because you weren’t there, you’re imaginary and you didn’t know the correct details, even from your own words in your own Koran.”

As for the “new creation”, it’s obviously a lie. For more, see: Creation and Repeat Creation.

Thus you know that Muhammad was a false prophet, for a false god, Allah, for a false religion, Islam, without even a false book, Koran.

The best replacement for this passage is: “”, the empty sentence.