Koran 24:47-54

24:47 But the hypocrites say, “We have believed in Allah and in the Messenger, and we obey”;

then a party of them turns away after that. And those are not believers.

48 And when they are called to [the words of] Allah and His Messenger to judge between them, at once a party of them turns aside [in refusal].

49 But if the right is theirs, they come to him in prompt obedience.

50 Is there disease in their hearts? Or have they doubted? Or do they fear that Allah will be unjust to them, or His Messenger? Rather, it is they who are the wrongdoers.

51 The only statement of the [true] believers when they are called to Allah and His Messenger to judge between them is that they say, “We hear and we obey.”

And those are the successful.

52 And whoever obeys Allah and His Messenger and fears Allah and is conscious of Him – it is those who are the attainers.

53 And they swear by Allah their strongest oaths that if you ordered them, they would go forth [in Allah’s cause].

Say, “Do not swear. [Such] obedience is known. Indeed, Allah is Acquainted with that which you do.”

54 Say, “Obey Allah and obey the Messenger; but if you turn away – then upon him is only that [duty] with which he has been charged, and upon you is that with which you have been charged. And if you obey him, you will be [rightly] guided. And there is not upon the Messenger except the [responsibility for] clear notification.”

Koran 24:47-54

Muhammad spoke about Allah in the third person. This means this passage is not the perfect words of the perfect Qur’an from perfect Allah. Thus, Allah is false, imaginary, and fictional, which means Islamic doctrine and Islam are nonsensical and false.

Muhammad Allah commands Muhammad to: “Say” or “Recite”. This means that this passage is addressed to Muhammad, not to all people. Thus, this passage can’t be in the perfect words of the perfect Qur’an from perfect Allah. As it is addressed to Muhammad, in his time and place, his context, this also means that this passage is locked to Muhammad’s context and can’t be in the context-free, perfect Qur’an from perfect Allah with all its perfect words. Thus, this passage is part of Muhammad’s recitation, Muhammad’s Koran, which means Islamic doctrine and Islam are incoherent and false, meaning Allah is incoherent, imaginary, fictional, and false.

Muhammad includes the imperfect words of imperfect others, an interlocutor who is only in Muhammad’s mind, instead of the perfect words of the perfect Qur’an from perfect Allah. This means that Muhammad’s recitation, Muhammad’s Koran, is not from Allah, which means Allah, Muhammad, Islamic doctrine, Islam, and Koran are incoherent and false.

Verse 47, Muhammad claims “But the hypocrites say, “We have believed in Allah””. What about the hypocrites who do not say exactly that? What about the one honest hypocrite who says, “I have believed in Allah and Muhammad, but now I know that believing in Muhammad is shirk, which means Allah, Islam and Koran is false!”.

And isn’t it hypocrisy and shirk to: “have believed in Allah and in the Messenger”? To believe in Muhammad as the equal of Allah? Surely, it’s better to believe in Allah, right? After all, Muhammad is dead, isn’t he? Why should anyone believe in the dead Muhammad for 1400 years, who will never come back, never give orders, will never do anything at all? So, aren’t the hypocrites who admit that they have believed in Allah and Muhammad, and then leave, because they know that believing in Muhammad is shirk – aren’t they the right ones? They know that believing in a mere man is wrong, so this demand to believe in Muhammad and Allah is wrong, thus Islam is false, thus Allah is false, thus Muhammad and Koran are false.

Verse 48

And when they are called to [the words of] Allah and His Messenger to judge between them, at once a party of them turns aside [in refusal].

Koran 24:48

How does Allah judge, when the judgement is by Allah the Just on the last day?

But, Infidel, it’s Allah and Muhammad who judge! How will that happen when Muhammad is dead and the last day hasn’t come for 1400 years? Thus, this passage is locked to Muhammad’s time and place, his context, showing that Islam and Allah are local to Muhammad, so Koran and Muhammad are false.

Verse 49

But if the right is theirs, they come to him in prompt obedience.

Koran 24:49

Notice the “him” is in lower case, showing that “him” is Muhammad – the Muslims are obeying not Allah, but Muhammad.

But, Infidel, by obeying Muhammad, they are obeying Allah! 1400 years later, how do we obey DEAD Muhammad?

But, Infidel, we obey Muhammad by reading his Koran! Muhammad’s Koran, right?

But, Infidel, Allah’s Qur’an! Where we are to obey, not Allah, but Muhammad: “they come to him in prompt obedience.”

But, Infidel, it’s meant that they come to Muhammad in obedience! I know, they can’t obey Allah, because there’s no way they can come to Allah, because Allah is imaginary and has no location (except in the Kaaba), thus requiring Muhammad to be alive. But again, how can we come to Muhammad in obedience when Allah is not present, and Muhammad is dead?

Verse 50

Verse 50 is a rhetorical question by Muhammad. There’s no need for this obfuscation from a real omniscient god, only for Muhammad who has difficulty in modelling the behaviour of others, people who say one thing and do another.

Verse 51

Verse 51 doesn’t account for the one believer. Note that the verse contains only plural. Also notice that it’s Muhammad providing justice, not Allah. After all, Allah only spoke to Muhammad when Muhammad was alive, not to Muhammad’s followers, right?

Or is it that Allah did indeed speak to Muhammad’s followers, showing that Allah possessed Muhammad, thus showing that Allah was a spirit, perhaps a demon, that possessed Muhammad, not a divine being who could speak to all?

Verse 52

And whoever obeys Allah and His Messenger and fears Allah and is conscious of Him – it is those who are the attainers.

Koran 24:52

How does one become conscious of Allah (“Him”), hmmm? For Muhammad it was easy:

I don’t have a demon pretending to be Allah on my shoulders.

What about you, the average Muslim?

No one is conscious of Allah.

Verse 53

Note in verse 53, it’s the Muslims obeying not Allah, but Muhammad, with: “that if you ordered them, they would go forth [in Allah’s cause].” The “you” here is Muhammad, thus showing it’s Muhammad speaking for Allah, thus showing that Muhammad is superior to Allah in authority.

But, Infidel, Allah is above Muhammad in authority here! I guess Muhammad got the words wrong then.

But, Infidel, it’s YOU who got the words wrong! Then why is “you” in lowercase”?

But, Infidel, it’s a translation issue! I see.

The best replacement for this passage is: “”, the empty sentence.