Koran 11:17

So is one who [stands] upon a clear evidence from his Lord [like the aforementioned]?

And a witness from Him follows it, and before it was the Scripture of Moses to lead and as mercy.

Those [believers in the former revelations] believe in the Qur’an.

But whoever disbelieves in it from the [various] factions – the Fire is his promised destination.

So be not in doubt about it.

Indeed, it is the truth from your Lord, but most of the people do not believe.

Koran 11:17

Note how the translators have to add “[stands]” and “[like the aforementioned]” to help make the rhetorical question make apparent sense. The translators forget that Muhammad has no evidence for Allah at all. Consider, if this first sentence of this verse came from Allah, then why are the translators adding to it? Allah is being corrected like a teacher correcting a child writing their first sentences on the blackboard.

Obviously, a corrected sentence, supposedly from Allah, is not evidence of Allah. Instead, it’s evidence and confirmation that Allah is false, an imaginary being in Muhammad’s head, that Muhammad animates and “speaks” to Muhammad when Muhammad wants. This first rhetorical question is evidence of Allah’s absence and falseness.

Muhammad gets confused: “And a witness from Him follows it” – yet how can others do that, when Muhammad requires people to listen to him recite the first 10 chapters, this chapter, and the next 100+ chapters of the Koran, yet to be recited by Muhammad? The Koran only became a book after Muhammad’s death. What this shows is that Muhammad is demoting himself again, down to merely a witness for Allah.

Muhammad admits: “before it was the Scripture of Moses to lead and as mercy.” The “Scripture of Moses”? So that’s equal or perhaps even greater than Muhammad’s Koran, which Muhammad claims comes from Allah, yet Allah is proven false in every chapter and passage? And we note that the Torah is not included in Muhammad’s Koran, not even the Decalogue, because it would expose the fact that Muhammad failed at each command from God.

Muhammad lied: “Those [believers in the former revelations] believe in the Qur’an.” But they don’t. The Jews remained Jews, despite Muhammad trying to convert them. The Christians remained Christian despite Muhammad trying to convert them. The Sabaeans were wiped out by Muhammad’s forces later. Also note the huge addition from the translators, to help make this sentence make sense: “[believers in the former revelations]”.

Muhammad lied: “But whoever disbelieves in it from the [various] factions…” – consider the “Children of Israel” listening to and reading the Decalogue, and then reading the later Torah – how are they to believe in Muhammad’s Koran, which comes 1000 years after their death long ago? Thus, obviously, if Allah is real and communicated the Torah to the Jews, then Koran is not needed for all the dead Israelites who followed Judaism to go to Islamic Paradise. Thus Muhammad’s Koran is pointless. Similarly for Christians, those who follow the “Scripture” or Bible and died in the 600 years after Jesus and before Muhammad was born, went mad and recited his mad poems. Muhammad’s Koran is unnecessary for those Christians. Similarly, the Zoroastrians and Sabaeans were admitted to Islamic Paradise by Allah, according to Muhammad, earlier in Muhammad’s Koran, just as good atheists and good whales are admitted to Islamic Paradise through the Noble or Royal door. Thus for all good religious people and good atheists and good whales before Muhammad produced his mad poetry, all were and are going to Paradise, and Muhammad’s Koran, Muhammad’s recitation, and Muhammad’s mad poems are not needed.

Thus because Muhammad’s bad poetry wasn’t needed in the past, so it’s not needed now. According to Muhammad, the Jews, Christians, Sabaeans, Zoroastrians, good atheists and good whales enter Heaven, and thus do not need Muhammad’s Koran, making the Koran pointless and worthless. And anyway, how does Muhammad teach his Koran to an already good whale? And what’s the point, they already get a free pass through the royal or noble door, something far greater than even the best Muslims of the first caliphate. Can you imagine a good whale converting to Islam? Obviously, it’s nonsensical and stupid, given the good whale already gets a better deal than by converting to Islam and being a Muslim.

Muhammad lied: “So be not in doubt about it.” But we doubt it because earlier Muhammad allows many people to go to Heaven without being Muslim or needing Koran. Thus only Muslims need Koran, and they would be better off being Christians or good atheists.

Muhammad forgets who is Allah: “Indeed, it is the truth from your Lord” – your Lord? Where are the words of Allah? Nowhere. This phrase shows that the true god of Islam is Muhammad, with his desire to be praised and obeyed.

Muhammad admits: “but most of the people do not believe.” This phrase locks Muhammad’s Koran to his time and place, his context. Indeed, Muhammad, all people should not believe in your mad poems in your recitation, of Muhammad the Mad’s Koran. As such, the best replacement for this verse is: “”, the empty sentence.